Powers of Appointment in Pennsylvania Estate Plans: The Overlooked-Holder Problem and Pennsylvania Law | Part 2
- 10 minutes ago
- 5 min read
In Part One of this series, we introduced powers of appointment — what they are, how they are classified, and how Pennsylvania estate planning attorneys use them to build flexibility into wills and trusts. In this installment, we turn to a problem that arises with troubling regularity: the holder who never knew the power existed. We also examine the Pennsylvania-specific legal framework that governs how these powers must be exercised — and what happens when they are not.
The Overlooked-Holder Problem
Here is an uncomfortable reality of estate planning practice: powers of appointment are frequently granted, and just as frequently ignored — not because holders do not care, but because no one told them the power existed.
A surviving spouse may receive a copy of a will or trust at the time of a spouse's death, skim it for provisions that affect daily finances, and file it away. Years later, when it matters, the power either goes unexercised entirely — or is exercised improperly through a will that does not satisfy the governing instrument's formality requirements.
Assets then pass under a default distribution provision that no one actually wanted. That outcome is both unintended and, in most cases, irrevocable.
The problem is compounded because exercising a power of appointment often demands specific language. Many Pennsylvania instruments require the holder to expressly reference the power in a will or deed of appointment. A general bequest such as "I leave everything to my children equally" may be legally insufficient — and the failure to exercise properly can produce lasting consequences that no amount of subsequent legal work can undo.
The Core Risk
A power of appointment that goes unexercised — or is exercised without the required formalities — is not just a missed opportunity. It can cause assets to pass to the wrong people in the wrong proportions, with no practical remedy after the fact.
Pennsylvania-Specific Legal Considerations
Governing Statutes: Pennsylvania Uniform Trust Act (20 Pa. C.S. §§ 7701 et seq.) and Pennsylvania Probate, Estates and Fiduciaries Code (20 Pa. C.S. § 2514 et seq.)
Pennsylvania's treatment of powers of appointment is governed primarily by the Pennsylvania Uniform Trust Act and the Pennsylvania Probate, Estates and Fiduciaries Code. These statutory frameworks shape how powers must be exercised, what constitutes a valid appointment, and how courts construe ambiguous or defective exercises. Several Pennsylvania-specific issues deserve particular attention:
Pennsylvania Inheritance Tax
Unlike many states, Pennsylvania imposes an inheritance tax on assets passing at death. The applicable rate depends on the relationship between the decedent and the beneficiary: 0% for a surviving spouse, 4.5% for direct descendants, 12% for siblings, and 15% for others. Whether a power of appointment causes assets to be included in the holder's taxable estate for Pennsylvania inheritance tax purposes depends critically on whether it is a general or limited power — a distinction that can translate to significant dollars in larger estates.
Federal Estate Tax Inclusion
A general power of appointment causes the subject assets to be included in the holder's gross estate for federal estate tax purposes under IRC § 2041, even if the power is never exercised. A properly structured limited (special) power generally avoids this inclusion — but the drafting must be precise and the classification must be intentional.
Creditor exposure under Pennsylvania law
In some circumstances, holding a general power of appointment can expose the subject assets to the holder's creditors under Pennsylvania law. This issue is highly fact-specific and is often overlooked until it is too late to address it through planning.
Spendthrift and discretionary trust protections
When a holder is also a beneficiary of the same trust that contains the power, the interaction between the power and the trust's spendthrift provisions requires careful analysis. Pennsylvania courts have examined these intersections in the context of both creditor claims and divorce proceedings, and the results are not always predictable.
Exercise formalities
Pennsylvania law and the governing instrument together determine what formalities are required to make a valid exercise. A poorly worded or misdirected exercise can be treated as a nullity — with assets then passing under the instrument's default provisions, often to the surprise and frustration of everyone involved.
Should Donors Tell Holders About the Power?
Pennsylvania law does not require a donor to notify a holder that a power exists. But the practical and human case for doing so is compelling. A power of appointment is only as useful as the holder's ability to exercise it knowingly and thoughtfully. Granting a power to someone who does not know it exists accomplishes very little.
Donors should consider the following steps when completing or updating their Pennsylvania estate plan:
1. Have a direct conversation.
Tell the intended holder, in plain language, that you are giving them this authority, what assets it covers, and what they can and cannot do with it. This does not need to be a formal meeting — it simply needs to happen.
2. Ask your attorney for a written plain-language summary.
A good Pennsylvania estate planning attorney should prepare a brief document describing the power — what it is, how it works, how it must be exercised under the governing instrument, and what happens if it is not. This can be stored with the trust or will and shared directly with the holder.
3. Identify the attorney of record and document location.
Make sure the holder knows who drafted the documents and where originals are kept. When the time comes, the holder will need competent Pennsylvania legal counsel — and knowing where to start matters enormously.
4. Revisit the conversation as family circumstances change.
Divorce, disability, a grandchild's birth, a child's financial difficulty — any of these may warrant revisiting whether the existing power still reflects the donor's intent, or whether an amendment is warranted.
Coming up in Part Three
In our final installment, we turn to the perspective of the holder. If you hold a power of appointment in a Pennsylvania will or trust, what are your obligations? What are the tax, creditor, and legal consequences you must consider? And what concrete steps should both donors and holders take to protect their interests and carry out their intentions? Part Three answers these questions with actionable guidance.
If you believe you may hold a power of appointment in a Pennsylvania will or trust — or if you are creating one for someone else — contact our estate planning team to discuss your situation.