Offer Letters – Why Business Owners Should Use Them When Hiring

For small businesses, an offer letter is a critical risk-management tool. It preserves the "at-will" nature of employment, prevents disputes over pay and benefits, and, most importantly, provides the legal authorization required by the Pennsylvania Wage Payment and Collection Law (WPCL) to make specific deductions from an employee’s paycheck. Without a signed writing, you may be legally barred from recouping bonuses or equipment costs if an employee leaves.

The Handshake Isn’t Enough: Why Your PA Small Business Needs Offer Letters

In the hustle bustle of running a business and hiring new employers, many owners rely on verbal agreements. However, when it comes to hiring, clarity is your best defense. A well-crafted offer letter serves three primary roles:

1. Affirming At-Will Status: 

It ensures both parties understand that employment can be terminated at any time, preventing "implied contract" claims.

2. Compliance with the WPCL: 

Pennsylvania law is strict about what can be taken out of a paycheck.

3. Setting the Stage: 

It professionalizes the onboarding process and eliminates "he said, she said" regarding compensation.

What Your Offer Letter Should Contain

To protect your business, ensure every letter includes these essentials:

1. Compensation and Classification

Avoid stating pay only as an annual sum (e.g., "$60,000 per year"), which can be misconstrued as a one-year guarantee. Instead, list the pay-period amount (e.g., "$2,307.69 bi-weekly"). Explicitly state if the role is Exempt (no overtime) or Non-Exempt (overtime eligible).

2. The "At-Will" Disclaimer

Explicitly state that the letter is not a contract for a fixed term and that the employment relationship remains "at-will."

3. Mandatory & Voluntary Deductions

Under Pennsylvania law, you generally cannot deduct money for the employer’s benefit without written consent. Your letter should include an Authorization for Deductions clause covering:

• Benefit premiums (health, dental, etc.).

• Retirement contributions.

• Recoupment of overpayments or unreturned company property.

4. Repayment Clauses for "Advanced Benefits"

If you are providing a sign-on bonus, a promise of training that you pay for or relocation assistance, you must include a "clawback" or repayment provision. This ensures that if the employee leaves within 12 or 24 months, the company can recoup a pro-rated portion of those funds.

Pro-Tip: Ensure this clause authorizes you to deduct the balance from the final paycheck, provided it doesn't drop a non-exempt worker below the minimum wage.

Best Practices for Pennsylvania Employers

Feature	Best Practice
Avoid "Forever" Language	Don't use phrases like "We see a long future for you here." Stick to: "We are excited for you to join our team."
Separate Agreements	Keep Non-Compete or Non-Disclosure Agreements as separate attachments. Reference them in the offer letter, but don't bake them into the same paragraph.
The Minimum Wage Floor	In PA, you cannot deduct so much from a final paycheck that the employee’s hourly rate falls below $7.25 for that period.
Contingencies	Clearly state the offer is contingent on background checks and I-9 verification.

A small investment in a robust offer letter today can save thousands in legal fees and Department of Labor audits tomorrow. By clearly outlining pay, at-will status, and deduction authorizations, you protect your cash flow and your peace of mind. 

GET YOUR FREE NEW HIRE CHECKLIST

Ready to Improve Your Hiring Process?

Navigating Pennsylvania’s unique employment landscape is a heavy lift for any small business owner. A single oversight in an offer letter can lead to costly disputes or administrative penalties.

Don’t leave your business unprotected. Whether you need a bulletproof offer letter template, a comprehensive employee handbook, or guidance on complex payroll deductions, the experienced attorneys at Fiffik Law Group, P.C. are here to help. We provide Pennsylvania small businesses with the legal infrastructure they need to grow with confidence.