top of page

Looking for Something Different?

Find posts related to the topic(s) you're interested in.

Understanding Privacy Laws in Pennsylvania: Can Your Neighbor Point a Camera at Your House?

security camera outside window of house

As home devices with cameras proliferate, discussions around privacy and surveillance have become increasingly important. One common concern among homeowners is whether it is legal for a neighbor to point a camera at their house. In Pennsylvania, there are specific laws and regulations in place to protect your privacy rights, including those related to surveillance and monitoring activities.  In Pennsylvania, while there is no legal requirement for neighbors to inform you of their surveillance activities, there are crucial legal considerations regarding privacy and reasonable expectation thereof.


Legal Considerations:


1. Reasonable Expectation of Privacy

Individuals have a reasonable expectation of privacy within their homes and in areas that are not in “plain sight.” Pennsylvania law generally permits surveillance of areas that are visible from a neighbor's property. This means that if an area or activity can be observed from the neighbor's property without the use of enhanced equipment, such as telescopes or drones, it may be legally surveilled.For example, it may be reasonable for a neighbor to have a camera pointed at your front yard to monitor for package deliveries or visitors. However, aiming a camera directly into your living room window could be seen as an invasion of privacy.

 

Scary fact:  Philadelphia ranks third in the highest number of surveillance cameras per 1,000 at 30.73. 

2. Audio Recording

Pennsylvania is a "two-party consent" state for audio recordings. This means that all persons involved in a conversation must consent to being recorded. This rule extends to conversations occurring on the phone or just between two people face to fact. One exception is recording someone in a public setting where there is no expectation of privacy.  For example, recordings at a public event would not violate this rule.  If your neighbor's surveillance includes audio recording of conversations that you are part of, you could have a strong case for legal action.  It may also be a crime:  recording without consent is a felony offense punishable by fines up to $15,000 and/or up to seven years in prison.


3. Use of Surveillance Footage

Even if the surveillance itself is legal, there are restrictions on how the footage can be used. Pennsylvania law prohibits the use of surveillance footage for purposes that violate another person's reasonable expectation of privacy or for any illegal activities, such as harassment or stalking.

 

Real-Life Scenario:

"I have a neighbor who just installed a security system. He has a camera pointed right at my front door and another that gives him a view of my backyard. I really don’t like this. Is there anything I can do about it?"

 

Steps to Take:

 

1. Dialogue with Your Neighbor

Before involving legal authorities, attempt to have a respectful conversation with your neighbor. They may not be aware of the impact their cameras are having on your privacy, and they might be willing to adjust their surveillance setup or agree on privacy boundaries.  If you cannot reach agreement with your neighbor or they are non-committal on making your requested changes, make it clear to your neighbor that you do not consent to any audio recordings and you should confirm that in writing. 


2. Physical Privacy Measures

Consider installing fences, planting trees, using blinds or curtains, or installing floodlights to "blind" the cameras and mitigate the impact of surveillance on your privacy.


3. Legal Guidance

If communication fails or if you believe your privacy is being unlawfully invaded, consult with an attorney. They can provide you with a clearer understanding of your rights and legal options under Pennsylvania law.  In some cases, a letter from your attorney threatening legal action for invasion of privacy, stalking, or harassment might prompt your neighbor to reposition the cameras to give you more privacy.


4. Further Legal Remedies

Depending on the severity of the invasion of privacy, remedies such as filing a lawsuit to seek court order (called an “injunction”) to stop the surveillance or pursuing damages for any harm caused may be an option to explore with your attorney.

 

Understanding the intricacies of privacy laws in Pennsylvania is crucial for protecting your rights while respecting the boundaries of others. Whether you are concerned about a neighbor's surveillance or considering installing your own security measures, being informed about the legal framework empowers you to navigate these situations effectively.

 

If you have further questions or concerns regarding privacy laws in Pennsylvania, the experienced attorneys at Fiffik Law Group can provide personalized guidance based on your specific circumstances. Remember, protecting your privacy is important, and knowing your rights is key to ensuring that your home remains a sanctuary of security and solitude.

Comments


bottom of page